as Invelos no longer sees my contributions as a significant value, I leave the building and stop contributing, don't gonna sit on average profiling a dvd for 8 hours and then see it blocked by always the same people. The joy of profiling is gone, so is the need for contributing.

Sorry for all who appreciated the little contributions I made. Put my Online Collection in the bin, changed my e-mail address.

no votes forced me back to the forum, the same people forced me to this decision, they finally succeeded and no longer have to cope with my contributions.

Quoting T!M:

Quote:
Quoting scotthm:

Quote:
What's much worse to my mind is the screeners ignoring them.  What's the point to voting "No" if the screeners are going to ignore valid objections?  They might just as well skip the voting process altogether.

Have you read Ken's stance on this, which I quoted for you on the previous page, at all? That the "standing policy is to accept profiles that add significant value"? That gives you all the answers...

invalid objections referring to rules that do no support these objections and still accepted by the screeners, making my contributions a less significant value?

The Hard Way 3259190359499.4

No Votes:
T!M:

Quote:
We don't do wholesale removal of (uncredited) cast data for no reason. Also: incorrect "sound" credits.

bmw850fan:

Quote:
see T.M

Graveworm:

Quote:
Not sure how hard you looked: http://ftvdb.bfi.org.uk/sift/individual/1015994?view=credit No reason to remove uncredited.

Han+Swolo:

Quote:
Agree with T.M

Invelos: Profile Contribution Declined Jun 28 2010  9:43AM

Quote:
An invalid source, such as a third party database, was listed in the contribution notes. Use of a third party database is not allowed per the contribution rules.

The contribution note for this profile:

Quote:
According the dvd, dvd cover, movie credits on dvd and the Invelos Credit Lookup: cast, crew, studios, overview & dvd details
removed all uncredited non documented cast (checked @ Invelos website)
Could not find IMDB independent evidence to demonstrate these are in the movie.

Evaluate this contribution

*Updated Notes*
According the dvd, dvd cover, movie credits on dvd and the Invelos Credit Lookup: cast, crew, studios, overview & dvd details
removed all uncredited non documented cast (checked @ Invelos website)
Could not find IMDB independent evidence to demonstrate these are in the movie.

The sound credits are well within the scope of the rules, I'm not the only user tracking these sound crew!
"Frank Graziadei" is credited in the following 29 titles (131 profiles)
"Albert Romero" is credited in the following 14 titles (44 profiles)

This is not a wholesale removal of uncredited cast. I really don't understand your objections. I have no problems with  uncredited actors as long as they are documented and not got imported from somewhere else!
After a thorough search I could find no non-imdb evidence that these uncredited cast is in this movie. If this were the case I had this documented, like I did on other occasions:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=contributionnotes&type=DVD&Profil
*Updated Notes*
According the dvd, dvd cover, movie credits on dvd and the Invelos Credit Lookup: cast, crew, studios, overview & dvd details
removed all uncredited non documented cast (checked @ Invelos website)
Could not find IMDB independent evidence to demonstrate these are in the movie.
bfi is same data as from idmb and most likely same source
The sound credits are well within the scope of the rules, I'm not the only user tracking these sound crew!
"Frank Graziadei" is credited in the following 29 titles (131 profiles)
"Albert Romero" is credited in the following 14 titles (44 profiles)

This is not a wholesale removal of uncredited cast. I really don't understand your objections. I have no problems with  uncredited actors as long as they are documented and not got imported from somewhere else!
After a thorough search I could find no non-imdb evidence that these uncredited cast is in this movie. If this were the case I had this documented, like I did on other occasions:

Location Crew & company name credits
Corne while the location crew in his contribution is accepted?

Quote:
Unit Crew isn't allowed by the rules: "Do not enter unit crew such as 'Unit Photographer'", the scans are great though

marnix64

Quote:
Images and info OK BUT RULES: Unit crew is specifically prohibited by the rules and should not be entered.

Quote:
Rules: List individual credits only, not company name credits. These company name credits should be left out.

Uncredited
T!M:

Quote:
We don't do wholesale removal of (uncredited) cast data for no reason

even if they are not appearing in the movie? Oh yeah can't touch these, as you brought these in 1st time contributions in your personal profiles.
ruben.:

Quote:
read contribute rules about uncedited cast

Graveworm:

Quote:
Not sure how hard you looked: http://ftvdb.bfi.org.uk/sift/individual/1015994?view=credit No reason to remove uncredited.

Ken you should put a health warning sign on dvd profiler and the forum.
Profiling can damage your health.

Catwoman: 7321932314502.30 1 yes 1 no: marnix64: not company name credits. These company name credits should be left out.

Catwoman: 7321932314502.9 12 yes 0 No
cvermeylen, Sokaris, Winnie, eommen, mark_b, Joost+Resink , reusla, Han+Swolo, Olaf73, janvg, stafked,
frank33_98

Sad to see you leave, I appreciated your contributions.

Donnie

scotthm I assume from the complaints and the tone.

If you don't like profiling per the rules, well, then don't do it.  Don't whinge about it.

Quoting gardibolt:

Quote:
scotthm I assume from the complaints and the tone.

If you don't like profiling per the rules, well, then don't do it.  Don't whinge about it.

No, it's not, please check your facts before speculating. 

And no, I don't know who ? is. *shrug*

Quoting Kulju:

Quote:
Who is/was he?

He used to go by "Giga Wizard", but the last time he left changed his forum alias into "." and now into "?".

Quoting Astrakan:

Quote:
Everything I do with my database I do it for me.

So you're not Bryan Adams then?