Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:
Not to mention on that Dirty Harry set... just like on Parent Trap set... it lists the titles at the bottom of the front cover. So how come with The Parent Trap set the titles at the bottom of the cover is part of "The Title" but the titles at the bottom of the Dirty Harry set they are not part of "The Title"?

Treating 2 releases that is done exactly the same way differently. As it seems just because not satisfied with the title of one of the sets.

This is exactly what I wanted to say in my last post: Why should we make differences? Just because in one example it's called Dirty Harry Collection and in the other case the one word misses? What if the cover would say The Parent Trap Collection? Treating different?

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:
Quoting TheMadMartian:

Quote:

Quote:
In the case of the OP, the the cover includes all of the following: 'The Parent Trap'; '2-Movie Collection'; 'The Parent Trap'; 'The Parent Trap II'.

In the case of 'The Dirty Harry Collection', the cover includes 'Clint Eastwood'.  Why are you dropping that from the title?

Not to mention on that Dirty Harry set... just like on Parent Trap set... it lists the titles at the bottom of the front cover. So how come with The Parent Trap set the titles at the bottom of the cover is part of "The Title" but the titles at the bottom of the Dirty Harry set they are not part of "The Title"?

Treating 2 releases that is done exactly the same way differently. As it seems just because not satisfied with the title of one of the sets.

I've already answered this numerous times.  'The Dirty Harry Collection' says it is a "Collection" so you know when you see the title it includes multiple films.

'Parent Trap' does not indicate in any way that it is a collection.  To see the title without paying attention to the edition), you would think it is simply the movie 'Parent Trap'.

Please support this with the rules... show me where we are allowed to add to the title if we feel the title isn't good enough.

Quoting VirusPil:

Quote:
Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:
Not to mention on that Dirty Harry set... just like on Parent Trap set... it lists the titles at the bottom of the front cover. So how come with The Parent Trap set the titles at the bottom of the cover is part of "The Title" but the titles at the bottom of the Dirty Harry set they are not part of "The Title"?

Treating 2 releases that is done exactly the same way differently. As it seems just because not satisfied with the title of one of the sets.

This is exactly what I wanted to say in my last post: Why should we make differences? Just because in one example it's called Dirty Harry Collection and in the other case the one word misses? What if the cover would say The Parent Trap Collection? Treating different?

If the cover said "The Parent Trap Collection", then , yes, that's all you would need to put in the Title field.  It i now clear that it is not the single movie 'The Parent Trap', but instead a collection of movies.

Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:

Please support this with the rules... show me where we are allowed to add to the title if we feel the title isn't good enough.

Do you see 'The Parent Trap' and 'The Parent Trap II' on the front cover of the DVD?

Quoting the Rules:

Quote:
Use the title from the front cover

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:

Please support this with the rules... show me where we are allowed to add to the title if we feel the title isn't good enough.

Do you see 'The Parent Trap' and 'The Parent Trap II' on the front cover of the DVD?

Quoting the Rules:

Quote:
Use the title from the front cover

Not as part of the title... no differently then I see Dirty Harry, Magnum Force, The Enforcer, Sudden Impact or The Dead Pool as not being part of the title of The Dirty Harry Collection title.

I see both exactly the same way... whether the word Collection is part of the title or not.

So next I would say Prove to me that those titles are part of the title for The Parent Trap... but at the same time prove that the Dirty Harry titles are not part of the title for The Dirty Harry Collection. Both are done EXACTLY the same way whether the word collection is shown or not.

Quoting VirusPil:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
I've already answered this numerous times.  'The Dirty Harry Collection' says it is a "Collection" so you know when you see the title it includes multiple films.

'Parent Trap' does not indicate in any way that it is a collection.  To see the title without paying attention to the edition), you would think it is simply the movie 'Parent Trap'.

Sorry, but what about Die Hard: The Ultimate Collection?
Am I the only one who thinks The Ultimate Collection is an Edition? 

It is an 'Edition' for each of the child profiles, but not for the boxset.

Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:

Please support this with the rules... show me where we are allowed to add to the title if we feel the title isn't good enough.

Do you see 'The Parent Trap' and 'The Parent Trap II' on the front cover of the DVD?

Quoting the Rules:

Quote:
Use the title from the front cover

Not as part of the title... no differently then I see Dirty Harry, Magnum Force, The Enforcer, Sudden Impact or The Dead Pool as not being part of the title of The Dirty Harry Collection title.

I see both exactly the same way... whether the word Collection is part of the title or not.

So next I would say Prove to me that those titles are part of the title for The Parent Trap... but at the same time prove that the Dirty Harry titles are not part of the title for The Dirty Harry Collection. Both are done EXACTLY the same way whether the word collection is shown or not.

Tell me why this is correct:

Title: Beach Blanket Bingo / How to Stuff a Wild Bikini
Edition: Midnite Movies Double Feature

and this is wrong:

Title: Midnite Movies Double Feature

After reading through all the post, and carefully weighing the options...

I believe the title is either

  The Parent Trap or
  The Parent Trap 2-Movie Collection.  <---- I prefer this one

To me, this is not different than Clint Eastwood American Icon Collection, where the 4 movies are listed on the cover, but are not included in the title.

As far as the argument for the other sets

Comedy double feature
Horror 4 movie set
etc...

I see these differently.  Typically I put these descriptors into the edition field  (Arthur/Arthur 2 :Comedy Double Feature)  They are more descriptive of a series of releases than they are of as a title (Otherwise we are going to have an awful lot of "Comedy Double Feature")

The fact that Parent Trap and Parent trap 2 are on the cover (at least the one that is presented), is not relevant to this argument, they fall into a sub category of the title, no different than Star Wars Trilogy, BTTF Trilogy.

(As fart as the title always from the cover, wasn't there a release of Batman that only had an image on the cover?)


Charlie