Quoting Alien Redrum:

Quote:
I'm going through mine now and ran across something interesting.

Beyond the Door is a two disc set with the rated version on one dvd and the unrated on another.

It is in my collection as a box set (not by me, though I understand why it is).

The parent is currently NR. The Unrated disc is NR. The Rated disc is R.

Now, to submit it, do I change the parent to "Unrated" (since it's the highest) or remove the rating altogether and re-submit it?

Secondly, I then change the child that's rated "NR" to "Unrated" and then re-submit that, is that correct?

Unrated, this part of the rule was and still is clear to me.

"For DVDs with more than one rating shown (e.g. a DVD which includes an R and Unrated version), use the highest applicable rating with the following scale:

NR < Board Rating < Unrated < Adult"

Plus that 2-disc Beyond teh Door is a special version (can't recall if it had it's own UPC or not, I think it did on the slipcover but may be wrong), most only had the unrated version in single disc form.

Quoting bigdaddyhorse:

Quote:
Quoting Alien Redrum:

Quote:
I'm going through mine now and ran across something interesting.

Beyond the Door is a two disc set with the rated version on one dvd and the unrated on another.

It is in my collection as a box set (not by me, though I understand why it is).

The parent is currently NR. The Unrated disc is NR. The Rated disc is R.

Now, to submit it, do I change the parent to "Unrated" (since it's the highest) or remove the rating altogether and re-submit it?

Secondly, I then change the child that's rated "NR" to "Unrated" and then re-submit that, is that correct?

Unrated, this part of the rule was and still is clear to me.

"For DVDs with more than one rating shown (e.g. a DVD which includes an R and Unrated version), use the highest applicable rating with the following scale:

NR < Board Rating < Unrated < Adult"

Plus that 2-disc Beyond teh Door is a special version (can't recall if it had it's own UPC or not, I think it did on the slipcover but may be wrong), most only had the unrated version in single disc form.

I would agree... if it is not really a boxset. But if it is a boxset... then boxset rules for the parent profile.

I don't think theatrical rating=theatrical release. It only means rating in a theatrical rating system.

It looks like a real funny mess that you (general you) have request. It seems that as usual very few had think at the real implications of this (so much will enter their personnal preferences in the database)...

Next time maybe it would be better to really think before asking Ken to enforce a personal preference, hope for you (general you) he will find a better way to deal with this in the next program update.

EVil Dead, Last House on the Left, Behind the Door, ... adult movies. Have fun with your mess

Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
So you would sit down with your 11 year old daughter and watch this movie together?

I'm sorry, but that's just not a good way of defining an "adult" work. Would you sit down with your 11 year old daughter and watch Halloween, Evil Dead, The Exorcist? What about adult comedies like Kingpin, Knocked Up, Clerks?

Do you want all those films to have an "Adult" rating?

No, but I don't want them to have NR which is the lowest rating either.

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
We're not talking about her seeing a boob.  This is full frontal male nudity.

I would *still* rather have her see a weiner than see someone brutally murdered.

Thankfully I am at the point where I really don't have to worry too much with either way any longer. But generally I agree Hal.

O.K., here's a fun one.

Ali Dircetor's Cut - UPC 043396090569

Case clearly says Unrated on back.
Then before the film plays, there's the blue rating card which says R for Some Language and Brief Violence.
Checked movieratings.com, and both versions are rated R for the same reasons.

So, does the cover win this for rating or do we go by reality like with runtimes and disc info/web info win?