Quote:
Mreeder:

I am afraid i don't see anything that indicates that Location Crew can be included. We have never allowed them to date. I suspect that you bassing your statement on the Location Unit but no mention at all of Location Crew and then supposing that Crew is Ok, which would be wrong. By that standard we should include any credit that is not specifically mention as unaccepatble, which would include Accountants, Grips, Caterers and so forth. Neither location crew or units are currently allowed under the Rules

Quote:
that's going to be a very lean & short Art Crew,

Quote:
In checking the rules, I see that UNIT Crew are specifically not allowed: "Do not enter unit crew such as "Unit Photographer"

But, I do not see where LOCATION Crew is banned. Can someone please point out exactly where in the rules this is spelled out.

All Crew members must be part of some Location Crew. Why should we omit Crew just because the specific locality is spelled out in the credits?

In my opinion, we don't. We only omit UNIT Crew. This is how I have contributed, and have had accepted, 4819 profiles.

Quote:
Mreeder:

I am afraid i don't see anything that indicates that Location Crew can be included.

Quote:
We have never allowed them to date.

Quote:
So does that mean that the US Crew should be removed from The Peacemaker profile?

Quote:
Kathy:

I did not attck YOU. I called your argument as I see it...Stupid. That does not mean you are stupid just your argument and it is both irrational and illogical to presume that if something is not specifically, emphasis on specifically, disallowed in the Rules then it is OK tyo include. I expect that you had better start including all such dataincluding the Accountants, Grips, best Boys, Lighting Techmnicians and so on and rest assured that if you do I will vote No to every Contribution made including such bull based upon your iillogical logic.

Quote:
Martian:


TThen I guess we can expect you to start including Music editors, or whatever else, after all they are not specificall allowed either. Your infallible logic is very fallible and completely illogical. And if you start fdollowing that in your Contributions I will be more than happy to give you a resounding No vote to every such Contribution using that as a basiss.

Quote:
You have no basis upon which to base your arguments most of the time, youy were NOT part of the original. You are not the authority, I am not saying or implying that I am, but you are only guessing and it's not even a good educated guess, it is merely your opinion based upon your own smoke and mirrors.

Quote:
Anmswers such as the ones I have seen is why it has taken me many years to even be willing to consider helping the Community with a Rules Team again.

Quote:
Pure unmitigated bull and people with such thin skins that cannot even put tohgether a cogent argument and instead say tripe like wewll it's not specifically excluded...give me a breaklk

Quote:
I amtrying very hard not  to beinsulting. Even though I do not suffer fools and stupidity very well, but this is one of the dumbest arguments I have ever seen.

Quote:
The Crew Chart lists all the valid Profiler credits.  Only people credited with one of those roles can be entered...the rules are pretty clear on that point, so anything else is automatically excluded, even if they aren't specifically mentioned.