Imagine that Corey change his vote... a lot of vote note wouldn't make sense anymore

Of course it won't happen as VFX artists aren't allowed (thanks I can in my database use the correct term), but that show the "agree with" comment aren't too usefull for the screeners in the case of an opinion shifting...

Quoting ateo357:

Quote:
All he is doing is adding correct info per the rules to an existing profile that has incorrect crew members he shouldn't be penalized for it.

He isn't being penalized, the people who won't have the benefit of his corrections are being penalized.  However, I blame the screeners as much as the "no" voters in a case like this.

---------------

Bigdaddy:
In the interest of data consistency, and rule consistency kat is correct. Personally I disagree but we must have consistency else we have nothing. Personally I would and have used vfx because it is shorthand for visual effects but...I use them custom and wait. I refuse to be a part of the problem and shoehorn data which is appropriate on one hand but technically outside the ruled on the other. I havesaid before that I would handle such issues in a much more timely manner were it up to me but it'd not. I also remain convinced that open crew credits and wysiwyt is the answer and will end these things. Users need to be able to contribute solid data, as much or as little as they wish and on the other side they simply need to be able to select that data in which they have an interest in.