Good evening, Sirs,

the contribution and adjudication procedure is still a mystery to me.

Recently I tried to correct a Studio from



to



And added:



Result: declined.

Now I wonder: what was wrong this time?

Love, bbbbb

What were your contribution notes?  Could you provide those?

If we knew what you wrote in your notes, What any no votes (if there was any) said and what (if any) the decline reason from invelos was it would help.

Quoting TheMadMartian:

Quote:
bbbbb's notes for "The Ward":

Quote:
Studios: corrected company name Premire -> Premiere Picture, like written in the opening credits.
Crew: added Jason McKee a 2nd time, he's first credited as Visual Effects Supervisor. (then, under North by Northwest, as VFX Artist)

Caution! The changes were verified with a Region B release.

The only thing I can think of is that you mention VFX Artist, and that is not a valid Profiler role.  I know you didn't add it but, other than taking the information from a Region B release, I can't see a problem with your contribution or notes.

Ah, I remember this contribution and that is why it was declined (in fact I voted no based on adding the VFX Artist).

Quoting TheMadMartian:

Quote:
The only thing I can think of is that you mention VFX Artist, and that is not a valid Profiler role.  I know you didn't add it

Of course not, the two VFX Artists along with their company divider were already in the profile:



I did not feel like starting an argument whether a "VFX artist" is a "Visual Effects" artist or not.

After all we already have Makeup artist, and the profile went through the hands of Katatonia, and if he did not see the need to remove the existing VFX artists why should I try.

So I just added the unquestionable "Visual Effects Supervisor", in compliance with The Rules.

Quote:
but, other than taking the information from a Region B release, I can't see a problem with your contribution or notes.

Quoting bbbbb:

Quote:
I did not feel like starting an argument whether a "VFX artist" is a "Visual Effects" artist or not.

After all we already have Makeup artist, and the profile went through the hands of Katatonia, and if he did not see the need to remove the existing VFX artists why should I try.

Don't be saying it went through my hands, because the person who added those Crew credits did so after my contribution. I never even touched the Crew credits, as can be evidenced by the contribution notes history of the profile in question.

Quoting bbbbb:

Quote:
Quoting TheMovieman:

Quote:

Quote:
The only thing I can think of is that you mention VFX Artist, and that is not a valid Profiler role.  I know you didn't add it but, other than taking the information from a Region B release, I can't see a problem with your contribution or notes.

Ah, I remember this contribution and that is why it was declined (in fact I voted no based on adding the VFX Artist).

You wrote: "Agree with Katatonia. VFX Artist is not on the crew table..."

Since when do we vote on contents that already are in the approved online profile?

Why should invalid crew be entered now, then for somebody else to copy in the future? It could've easily been removed before submitting (since in your notes you knew about it).

But if the contribution is correct according to the rules, is it then correct to vote "no" because an existing error wasn't corrected?